Friday, May 31, 2013

The "Lion of the Jurassic" fed like a falcon

People seem to think that giant predatory dinosaurs were absolute monsters. Of course, they were monstrous in size, with some species reaching upwards of 50ft in length. However, just because they attained these great sizes does not mean they were reckless, ruthless killers. The more we discover about the giant theropods, the more we are able to compose a lifelike and accurate picture of their biology. In recent years, technological advances have allowed us to take a look not only at the surface of fossils, but test their strength and stress under conditions which they would have faced in life.

Recently, the juggernaut theropod Allosaurus, the lion of the Jurassic, was the subject of a study on feeding mechanisms. Combining engineering and technology with a biological perspective allowed Eric Snivley and his team from Ohio University to examine the living mechanics of the predator and determine how it would have fed. They determined that, although Allosaurus was a large predator, it had a very light skull, and its muscles were not suited for vigorous shaking as much as they were for plucking and tearing at flesh.

Allosaurus and Falco. Image coutresy of WitmerLab, Ohio University.

A major find from this study was the placement of the longissimus capitis superficialis muscles on Allosaurus' neck. These muscles, Snivley explains, are comparable to "a rider pulling on the reins of a horse's bridle." If a muscle on either side contracts, then the head moves in that direction, allowing the head to shake from side to side. However, if both muscles contract, the head is pulled directly down. On Allosaurus, these muscles were located very low on the skull, and indicated that the animal drove its head into its prey, held it there, and then tore straight back and up ( This feeding strategy can be seen in modern raptors, including kestrels.

The Jurassic Paleodiet
This comparatively delicate method of feeding, along with the animal's lightweight skull, raise some interesting questions. Allosaurus is commonly portrayed hunting and feeding on the huge sauropods with which it shared its environment. It is true that Allosaurus likely hunted with hatchet-like movements of its skull, slashing through skin and muscle and bleeding out its prey; however, I believe that the possibility of Allosaurus hunting adult sauropods is becoming slimmer and slimmer with each new discovery we make.

Although it was the most abundant large carnivore of the late Jurassic (at least in North America and Europe), it probaby did not hunt the most abundant herbivores, which were the sauropods. I'm sure that allosaurs attempted to tackle juveniles frequently, and probably with some success, but the bulk of their prey likely consisted of animals which were much easier to tackle. Small ornithopods, juvenile stegosaurs, and other small herbivores, as well as small carnivores and many non-dinosaurian prey items, were likely higher of a priority to Allosaurus than the titanic sauropods.

Sunday, May 19, 2013

Mock-turtles and Reptilian Otters: The pioneering placodonts

Throughout the Mesozoic, marine life was dominated by reptiles of all shapes and sizes. Some of the most bizarre and striking species lived at the very beginning of the era, during the Triassic period. Among ridiculously long-necked protorosaurs and ichthyosaurs as large as sperm whales lived a family of very bizarre, and extremely specialized, animals known as the placodonts.

Placodonts, meaning "flat teeth," were a family of reptiles which lived across the globe and only survived during the Triassic. They were not giants like so many others; the largest species grew to 3m (10ft) long. They were not superpredators, nor were they diminuitive prey items. In fact, at first glance, there doesn't appear to be anything too exciting about them. But to see what makes placodonts so special, we need to look in their mouths.

The placodont Placodus, a bizarre chimera of marine iguana and sea otter. Reconstruction by Dan Varner.
The placodonts weren't named for nothin'. They were armed with almost stone-like, crushing teeth which were perfect for crushing shellfish. These were the first - and last, for a very long time - reptiles to specialize in eating hard-shelled invertebrates. For a long time, the origins of these very specialized reptiles was unknown. Recently, however, fossils of the most basal placodont known were discovered. This specimen, dubbed Palatodonta bleekeri, lacked the crushing teeth of its later relatives - instead, it had small, sharp, peg-like teeth, perfect for gripping much softer prey (Neenan et. al, 2013). These teeth, in comparison, are nothing special in the world of reptiles.

The basal placodontiform Palatodonta bleekeri. Reconstruction by Jaime Chirinos.
The Triassic, as discussed in a previous post, was an age of extremely rapid radiation, with reptiles of all sorts quickly evolving to fill any and all niches left open by the Permo-Triassic Extinction. In oceans filled with species adapted to feed on fish and cephalopods, the placodonts evolved a niche avoided by all other reptiles: scouring the sea floor for bivalves and other hard-shelled goodies.

The "mock-turtle" Henodus. Despite all similarities, it was a placodont, not even closely related to true turtles. Reconstruction by Jim Robbins.
In their day, the largest placodonts were too large to be preyed upon by most animals in their environment - smaller sharks and fish-eating reptiles were the only others to share the shallow seas in which they swam. However, as marine predators began to evolve, the placodonts had to adapt: many species evolved bony armor. This armor may cause some confusion, as some armored species were so well-protected that, at first, they look just like turtles, which had yet to evolve. Some species, such as the 2m (6ft) Psephoderma, took this armor to even greater lengths, with articulated "suits" of armor which allowed for greater mobility in the water.

Another mock-turtle, Psephoderma, and a nothosaurid. Illustration by Kahless28 on deviantArt.
The placodonts were true pioneers in the world of reptiles. They were the first reptiles to evolve a bony shell, and some of the first animals to exploit a niche which would later be filled by animals such as sea otters. Unfortunately, like so many unique species of the Triassic, they disappeared at the end of the period, paving the way for shellfish-eating sharks, turtles, and a myriad of other sea-going oddities.

References
James M. Neenan, Nicole Klein, Torsten M. Scheyer. 2013. European origin of placodont marine

reptiles and the evolution of crushing dentition in Placodontia. Nature Communications. March 27, 2013. doi:10.1038/ncomms2633

Thursday, May 9, 2013

The "Dinosaurs" that Weren't: The [brief] Age of Pseudosuchians

Circa 250Ma (million years ago), the Paleozoic Era came to a dramatic close. The devastating Permian-Triassic Extinction, aptly nicknamed the "Great Dying," saw the extinction of over 90% of marine species and 70% of terrestrial species, and was the largest extinction in Earth's history. It may have taken the planet a whopping 10 million years to recover from the event. When the planet did recover, the landscape was not dominated by synapsids or amphibians anymore: this was the great Age of Reptiles, the Mesozoic. But the Mesozoic's most famous inhabitants, the dinosaurs, did not start out as the masters of the earth. In the Triassic, the world belonged to the false-crocodiles.

A psampling of pseudosuchians. Pictured are rauisuchians (top and bottom rows), an aetosaur (middle row, left), and a phytosaur (middle row, right). Illustrations by N. Tamura.

Enter the great clade of Pseudosuchia. One of the two major groups within Archosauria, which also includes dinosaurs and pterosaurs, the pseudosuchians are an incredibly diverse group of reptiles which had their 50 million years of fame at the very beginning of the Mesozoic. In the wake of such a large extinction, the pseudosuchians were the first to fill any and all empty niches. In fact, the pre-dinosaur world was very, well, dinosaurian in appearance: bipedal predatory juggernauts hunted low-lying, heavily-armored herbivores, while enormous crocodile-like hunters stalked the waterways. The shapes and sizes of these Triassic pseudosuchians can be thought of as a sort of biological foreshadowing for species yet to evolve, including theropods, ankylosaurs, and crocodiles.

The fauna of Triassic Arizona. All species pictured, except the ones with the big X's, are pseudosuchians, composing the majority of life on land, as well as major predators in the water.  Reconstruction by Jeff Martz. X's by yours truly.

The Triassic pseudosuchians experienced a period of extremely rapid, and greatly successful, evolution: the small, agile reptiles which had arisen in the beginning of the period had evolved into the dominant terrestrial predators by the middle, and by the end of the period they dominated all aspects of life. In fact, in this relatively short period of time, they had even more diverse habits and appearances than early dinosaurs. A comparison of Triassic archosaurs and phytosaurs revealed that early dinosaurs were half as diverse as other closely-related reptiles, including pseudosuchians, and displayed little difference in their anatomy and habits throughout the period (Brusatte et. al, 2008). 

Clearly, the extinction of the pseudosuchians of the Triassic does not mean they were inferior to their successors. Quite the opposite is true. Had the larger species not gone extinct at the end of the Triassic, it is likely that the pseudosuchians would have maintained their comfortable position as masters of the land. In fact, the body plans of several Triassic pseudosuchians were repeated by dinosaurs much later in history. Rather than competition or lack of resources, it is likely that large pseudosuchians went extinct due to a period of rapid global warming, leaving smaller species that lived in the shadows of increasingly abundant dinosaurs.

Although the dominant pseudosuchians went extinct at the end of the Triassic, suchians in general still thrived. Pictured are Paul Sereno and a variety of crocodylomorphs which once inhabited North Africa during the Cretaceous.

However, not all was lost for the pseudosuchians. One subgroup, Suchia, the "true crocodiles," contains some of the only surviving archosaurs: the crocodylians. The suchians, alongside the dinosaurs, reigned in the Mesozoic, evolving to fill a wide variety of niches, from insect-eaters to marine predators to species large enough to eat large dinosaurs. But even with their extreme diversity during the rest of the Mesozoic, the pseudosuchians would never again be the true masters of the planet in the way they were during the Triassic.

References

Brusatte, Stephen L., Michael J. Benton, Marcello Ruta, and Graeme T. Lloyd. 2008. “Superiority, Competition, and Opportunism in the Evolutionary Radiation of Dinosaurs.” Science 321 (5895) (September 12): 1485–1488. doi:10.1126/science.1161833.

Friday, May 3, 2013

Jurassic Park 3D: A some-expenses-spared review

I'm not going to rehash the influence of Jurassic Park, nor am I going to point out its paleontological flaws. I've already done that enough. All I want to say in this post is that Jurassic Park 3D is a living, breathing, reminder as to why the movie was so tremendously popular and not only changed public reception and expectation of recreated dinosaurs, but changed the world of film itself.


As I was talking to my younger brother about JP3D, he made a good point: it is the quintessential "'that's-why-we-go-to-the-movies' movie", as he put it. It's got everything a classic movie needs: thrills, chills, laughs, beauty, depth, dinosaurs... As Lex says after rebooting the park's power, "you name it, we got it!" It's more than just a bunch of CGI an animatronic dinosaurs chasing hapless humans around a tropical island. And even if you can't appreciate the plot elements of JP (I'm aware it's not the greatest movie out there [but definitely in my Top 5, jus' sayin']), the technology behind it is breathtaking.

Even the animatronic dinosaurs still look lifelike in Jurassic Park 3D.
Think about it: Jurassic Park came out in 1993. With minimal retouching of the CGI models, even in 3D, the dinosaurs still are more lifelike than any that have graced the silver screen since its release (the only exceptions, perhaps, being the other JP films). To this day, watching the female tyrannosaur heavily pad its way after the flare that Grant threw is still entirely convincing. When the duo of Velociraptors strut into the kitchen, you feel as if you are right there with them. When I saw that monumental Brachiosaurus for the first time on the big screen, I was just as in awe as the characters in the film.


To this day, Jurassic Park has the ability to make animals long gone from this planet look entirely real, even if they majorly lack on accuracy. Even now, when we have movies made entirely with computers, Jurassic Park holds its own in every aspect, from acting to visual effects. If you haven't seen JP3D yet, you must. It's a real reminder of the power of technology, whether you pay attention to the movie itself or the story behind it.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Microraptor: Crow of the Cretaceous

Most of what we know about the diet of extinct animals comes from looking at their teeth, with obvious reasons. We can easily tell which animals were suited for slicing through flesh and which could easily grind vegetation, or which had teeth and jaws perfect for catching fish. There are a few instances, however, when we are lucky enough to actually find the preserved stomach contents of extinct animals. These findings, more than teeth or jaws, provide the most complete picture of what extinct animals were eating.

I've mentioned the diminuitive microraptorine Microraptor gui in a previous post. This little dromaeosaur has provided an enormous amount of information on not only the evolution of feathers and flight in non-avian dinosaurs, but it has revealed startling clues about its own habits. Like most other dromaeosaurs, M. gui was a predator, likely feeding on mammals, insects, and other small prey. In 2011, a specimen of M. gui was found with the fragments of bird bones in its stomach, indicating that it was an adept aerial hunter capable of taking out smaller, feathery prey on the wing (O'Connor et. al, 2011). This specimen revealed that Microraptor was, definitively, an arboreal hunter. However, just last week, another specimen of Microraptor revealed something even more surprising.

The new specimen of Microraptor. The preserved fish scales can be seen in the magnifying glass. Photograph by Scott Persons.
It turns out that the largest specimen of Microraptor, which also contains the remnants of its last meal, was preserved with fish scales in its stomach (Xing et. al, 2013). Did the specimen in question hunt the fish it was preserved with, or was it washed upon the shore of an ancient lake? These are questions we can't determine through fossils; however, Microraptor does not display any particular adaptations for fishing. The animal probably scavenged the fish, or managed to catch it in very shallow water. Either way, this changes our perception of the dromaeosaur in a very unexpected way. Instead of regarding Microraptor as a skilled arboreal hunter, which it most certainly was, it appears that the little glider was more of an opportunist than we imagined.

Microraptor eating a fish. Whether the specimen hunted the fish or was scavenging remains uncertain. Reconstruction by Emily Willoughby.
Between the discovery of the color of Microraptor, and clues about its generalist lifestyle, it seems as though Microraptor was the Cretaceous equivalent of a crow. Hopefully, more specimens are unearthed with stomach contents in tact. I wouldn't be surprised if we found stomach contents revealing something like this...

Microraptor gui feeding on a cycad. Reconstruction by Emily Willoughby.

References
O’Connor, Jingmai, Zhonghe Zhou, and Xing Xu. 2011. “Additional Specimen of Microraptor Provides Unique Evidence of Dinosaurs Preying on Birds.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (November 21). doi:10.1073/pnas.1117727108. http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/11/17/1117727108.

Xing, Lida, W. Scott Persons, Phil R. Bell, Xing Xu, Jianping Zhang, Tetsuto Miyashita, Fengping Wang, and Philip J. Currie. 2013. “Piscivory in the Feathered Dinosaur Microraptor.” Evolution: n/a–n/a. doi:10.1111/evo.12119.

Monday, April 15, 2013

The extreme diversity of Accipitridae

In classification, families range from being pretty well-defined to diverse beyond belief. The family Accipitridae falls into the latter category. Accipitridae includes most species birds of prey, collectively known as raptors. At first glance, the diversity of the family appears to be too great to be supported by anything but morphological; however, karyotypic data has supported the theory that the accipitrids are monophyletic (that is, sharing a common ancestor). Though most of the birds of prey are accipitrids, not all species are included: the secretary bird, owls, New World vultures, and the osprey are all included in families of their own due to genetic differences.

At first glance, raptors may appear to be very similar. To demonstrate just how diverse this family is, I've chosen a representative from each of the subfamilies of Accipitridae. A very special "thank you" to Gareth Monger, who created the following visual. All raptors are to scale, although some of them may be skewed due to odd angles.

Click to embiggen.

1. Bearded vulture (subfamily Gypaetinae) - Also known as the lammergeyer, it feeds on marrow by dropping bones from great heights. It also uses this technique to feed on tortoises.

2. Snail kite (subfamily Milvinae) - The long upper jaw of this raptor allows it to feed almost exclusively on snails, though it will also eat crustaceans and fish as well.

3. Dark chanting-goshawk (subfamily Melieraxinae) - Couldn't find anything particularly unusual about this species. Sorry, folks.

4. Harris hawk (subfamily Buteoninae) - The only raptor to actively hunt in familiar packs.

5. Pearl kite (subfamily Elaninae) - The second-smallest raptor in the world. Preys mainly on Anolis sp. lizards.

6. Black baza (subfamily Perninae) - Captures insects on the wing, or plucks them off of leaves. It has also been observed eating palm fruit.

7. Philippine eagle (subfamily Circaetinae) - Also known as the monkey-eating eagle. It also preys on anything from monitor lizards to hornbills.

8. Steller's sea eagle (subfamily Haliaeetinae) - Feeds mainly on fish, though also hunts waterfowl, gulls, herons, and cranes.

9. African harrier-hawk (subfamily Polyboroidinae) - Its "double-jointed" legs can bend forwards and backwards, allowing it to raid the nest cavities of smaller birds for fledglings.

10. Cinereous vulture (subfamily Aegyptiinae) - The world's largest true raptor. Reported to fly very close to herds of wild sheep, perhaps in order to pick out potential prey.

11. Harpy eagle (subfaimly Harpiinae) - Hunts mostly sloths, though large monkeys are also eaten.

12. Shikra (subfamily Accipitrinae) - Feeds on everything from termites to bats to birds. It often uses metal wire as part of its nest.

13. Verreaux's eagle (subfamily Aquilinae) - A hyrax specialist, though it will also hunt small antelope and other animals.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Out of Africa: The diversity and extinction of Africa's oldest penguins

Not many people realize how diverse penguins are. Usually associated with the frigid wastes of Antarctica, penguins are actually spread throughout all continents in the southern hemisphere, and range in habitat from pack ice to sandy beaches to fern forests. Out of all penguins, one sticks out from the rest, purely due to its range and habitat: the African penguin, Spheniscus demersus. This little penguin, about 2ft tall, nests among boulders on none other than the sunny, sandy shores of South Africa and Namibia.

Modern African penguins in their natural habitat.

It may seem odd to us that a penguin could find a suitable place to nest somewhere so warm, compared to the cooler climes of other species. However, penguins have been present in Africa for much longer than previously thought. New fossils from the Saldanha Steel formation near Cape Town are not only the oldest evidence of African penguins, they also show just how diverse the area was.

During the mid- to late Miocene, some 10-12Ma, sea levels were much higher than they are today: in the heyday of the African penguin, the sea was a full 90m higher than present levels. This not only provided much more swimming space, but it created a small archipelago. Penguins, being flightless birds and rather clumsy on land, prefer nesting in isolated areas such as islands; this eliminates the threat from large terrestrial predators. The ample nesting space could support a variety of species with no competition between them.

Modern sea level at Saldanha Steel (A) and during the early Pliocene (B), when the sea was 90m higher than today. The scattered islands in B would have been critical nesting grounds for penguins. From Roberts et. al, 2011.
Clearly, the higher sea levels were a blessing for the ancient penguins, for not one, not two, but four new species were uncovered from Saldanha Steel. The largest of these was as tall as the modern king penguin, the second-largest living species. The smallest was about as large as the smallest living species, the little blue penguin. The other two were comparable in size to the modern African penguin. The species were already very "modern" in appearance; penguins are among the oldest families of birds, and quickly evolved into recognizable species.

A brief history of African penguins. The four newly-discovered species are silhouetted in gray. From Thomas & Ksepka, 2013.

I imagine the scene at Saldanha Steel would have been very similar to modern nesting colonies of penguins, which would have been a site to behold, especially when you realize that scenes like this one would have taken place in Africa.

A colony of king penguins on the island of South Georgia. Perhaps Saldanha Steel would have boasted a much similar scene, with even more diversity, some 10Ma. Photograph by Arthur Morris.

As sea levels receded to their modern levels, the islands on which the penguins nested connected with the mainland, allowing predators to invade. Could predation have led to the extinction of these penguins? Or was it the disappearance of crucial nesting space? It's likely that the penguins were more and more pressed to find adequate nesting grounds, and the curtain was drawn with the arrival of large terrestrial predators. No matter what the cause of their extinction, it is fascinating to picture the diversity of penguins which once roamed South Africa, surely the last place we would readily associated with those clumsy, comical birds.